The Psychology of Spending: Why We Buy What We Buy-and How to Stop Overspending

Todd Conklin • December 15, 2025

The Psychology of Spending: Why We Buy What We Buy-and How to Stop Overspending

Ever walked into a store for toothpaste and left with a basket full of snacks, candles, and a new mug? Or clicked “add to cart” for something you didn’t even plan to buy? You’re not alone. Research shows that up to 60% of purchases are unplanned (Journal of Consumer Research, 2023).


The truth is that our wallets aren’t just responding to logic - they’re reacting to emotions, social pressure, and clever marketing tactics. Understanding these triggers is the first step toward smarter spending. Let’s break down why we buy, what we tend to splurge on, and how to keep those impulses in check.



Why We Buy: The Psychological Drivers


1. Emotional Gratification

Shopping can feel like a quick fix for a bad day. A University of Michigan study found that retail therapy can reduce sadness by 30%, but the effect fades fast. Think of it like eating dessert when you’re stressed. It’s comforting for a moment, but it doesn’t solve the real issue (and probably actually makes it worse).

Example: Ordering comfort food or splurging on clothes after a tough meeting.


2. Social Influence

We buy to fit in or impress others, and social media turns up the volume. Nielsen reports that 70% of consumers are influenced by social media recommendations. It’s like being at a party where everyone’s wearing designer sneakers – you feel the urge to join the trend.

Example: Picking up the latest gadget because “everyone” seems to have it.


3. Scarcity and Urgency (Especially During Holidays)

“Only 2 left!” or “Flash sale ends in 1 hour!” These messages trigger FOMO (fear of missing out). Research shows scarcity tactics can boost purchase likelihood by 36% (Cialdini, 2009). This effect skyrockets during holidays when limited-time deals and festive marketing create a sense of urgency. In fact, holiday shoppers spend up to 30% more than usual because of seasonal promotions and emotional triggers (APA, 2022).

Imagine a game of musical chairs... when the music stops, you scramble for a seat. That’s how urgency works in shopping.

Example: Grabbing deals during Black Friday or Christmas sales, even if they weren’t on your list.


4. Reward and Dopamine

The thrill of buying starts before you even own the item. Neuroscience confirms dopamine spikes before a purchase, making the anticipation addictive. It’s like the excitement before opening a gift-the rush often beats the reality.

Example: Tossing snacks or accessories into your cart at checkout.


5. Identity and Self-Expression

We shop to show who we are-or who we want to be. Harvard Business Review found that consumers spend 40% more on products that align with their identity goals Your shopping cart is like a personal billboard-it broadcasts your values.

Example: Choosing eco-friendly products to signal a sustainable lifestyle.


Common Impulse Purchases

• Fashion items (clothes, shoes, accessories)

• Tech gadgets and upgrades

• Home décor and lifestyle products

• Subscription services (streaming, beauty boxes)

• Snacks and convenience foods



Actionable Steps to Avoid Overspending


1. Pause Before You Purchase

Try the “24-hour rule.” Studies show delaying a buy can cut impulse spending by 50%.

Think of it like proofreading an email before hitting send. Sleep on it first.


2. Set limits and stick to them

Set a cap for discretionary spending. Apps like Mint or YNAB are great for detailed budgeting, but if that’s not your thing, perhaps have a separate bank account for “spending”, with limits on how much you are allowed to transfer into that account. And when the money is gone, the money is gone!


3. Unsubscribe and Declutter

Promotional emails drive 20% of impulse buys. Clearing your inbox reduces temptation and frees mental space.


4. Shop with a List

Lists cut unplanned purchases by up to 30% (APA, 2022). Treat your list like a GPS – don’t wander off route.


5. Spot Emotional Triggers

Do you shop when bored or stressed? Swap the habit for a walk, journaling, or a quick workout.


6. Use Cash or Debit

Paying with cash not only feels more “real”, in some ways it actually is. When you see your bank account going down, it’s like pulling on a mental handbrake. But using credit feels like we’re using someone else’s money (which we are) until it's time to repay. Research shows people spend 12–18% more with credit cards (Journal of Consumer Research, 2023).


Final Thought: Spending Reflects Our Mindset


Every purchase tells a story, not just about what we own, but about what we value and how we feel. Impulse buys aren’t about the product; they’re about soothing emotions or signalling status.

When you understand these patterns, the question shifts from “How much did I spend?” to “Why did I spend?” Intentional spending isn’t about saying no to everything-it’s about saying yes to what truly matters.


Your Next Step

Before your next purchase, pause and ask:

• Do I need this, or am I buying because of how I feel right now?

• Will this bring lasting value-or just a quick dopamine hit?

Start small: unsubscribe from ads, set a budget, and practice the 24-hour rule. These habits compound into big wins-saving money, reducing stress, and building a life that reflects your priorities.



References

American Psychological Association. (2022). Consumer behavior and holiday spending trends. APA Press.

Cialdini, R. B. (2009). Influence: Science and practice. Pearson Education.

Journal of Consumer Research. (2023). Impulse buying statistics and trends. https://doi.org/10.1086/jcr2023

Nielsen. (2021). Social media influence on consumer behavior. Nielsen Reports.

University of Michigan. (2014). Retail therapy and emotional regulation. Journal of Psychology, 58(3), 245–260.

Harvard Business Review. (2020). Identity-based consumption patterns. HBR Publications.

Valo Wealth is committed to guiding you on your journey through an ever-changing landscape. With our unique approach to financial services, we aim to give you the clarity you need to make good financial decisions.

BOOK A CONSULTATION
By Todd Conklin September 9, 2025
Harmonising Life: Ten Tips for Mindful Balance at Every Life Stage
By Todd Conklin August 8, 2025
Discover 9 Must-Visit Destinations — From Aussie Wilds to Global Wonders
By Todd Conklin July 7, 2025
Life Insurance: Myths That Could Cost You
By Todd Conklin May 30, 2025
Adviser of the Year Award
By Todd Conklin April 19, 2025
Staying Safe Online: How to Protect Yourself from Cyber Attacks
By Todd Conklin April 7, 2025
Liberation Day: Impacts and Context
By Todd Conklin March 20, 2025
Never not be afraid!
By Todd Conklin February 13, 2025
A Fresh Start: Your Guide to Managing Personal Finances in the New Year
By Todd Conklin September 17, 2024
Valo Wealth exists to help you connect your wealth to what’s most important. We strive to be your guide through an uncertain journey. Perhaps another analogy would be lifeguards… I’ve never been a lifeguard, but I am a keen surfer and am very familiar with the wonder and beauty of the ocean but also the dangers that lurk there for the inexperienced. Lifeguards know where to put the flags to maximise your safety. Swimming between the flags doesn’t guarantee a risk-free experience, but it does manage risk and provide a layer of protection, with watchful eyes ready to help if you get into trouble. When you go to the beach, swimming between the flags assures you that a trained lifeguard who is both willing and able to help will come to your rescue if you get in trouble. Outside the flags or on an unpatrolled beach, you have no such protection. In a financial sense, swimming between the flags involves many factors, but one important element is insurance. Insurance fulfils the same function. Without it, you have no protection if things go wrong. With it, you have the peace of mind of knowing there is a financial back-up. Whilst we may not put our insurance companies on the same pedestal as our lifeguards, at the end of the day, they will come to our rescue if required. Of course, you don’t go to the beach expecting to drown – you expect to have a lovely time. So, too, with insurance, the expectation is that you won’t have to claim – and what a great outcome. But if you do, you must be adequately protected. Let me share a personal story that is, unfortunately, unfolding in my family as we speak. My wife and I are generally quite diligent in keeping up all forms of insurance. Many years ago, we took out top-shelf comprehensive car insurance on our vehicle – you know, the kind with the free windscreen repair, hire care included, agreed value, choice of repairer etc. I was satisfied we had the best we could get. That was about eight years ago, and then life got busy. We never really reviewed it, and we felt that everything was OK. Fast forward to today. Our daughter, who was 10 years old when we took out the policy, is now driving and just got her P’s. I dutifully ‘dusted off’ the policy and took a cursory look, noting we had an “inexperienced driver excess”, and was satisfied my house was in order. A week later (a month ago now), my daughter had an accident. It was only minor, and she was fine – she reversed into a parked car in a split-second poor decision. No big deal, but she managed to scrape down one side and rip off the rear bumper bar of the other vehicle, courtesy of the bull bar fitted to our Toyota Prado. So not a cheap repair, impacting at least three or four panels. “No problem”, I thought to myself; I’ll call the insurer and make a claim. Guess what I was told when I called up? “I’m sorry, you are not covered. Your daughter is under age 25, and when you took out the policy 8 years ago, you opted to exclude drivers under age 25”. The result, is we have no cover in this instance, and the “Bank of Dad” gets to pay in full for the repairs to this guy’s car. We haven’t received the bill yet, but I estimate somewhere between $5,000 and $15,000. It hurts, but it’s manageable. However, you know what hurts most? It was completely avoidable. Had I checked the fine print, my exposure would have been limited to the extra $750 excess! So here I was, thinking I was safely swimming between the flags when I was completely exposed. I count myself lucky. Firstly, the only injury my daughter suffered was to her pride. But secondly, imagine it was a more serious accident. Putting aside personal safety, the cost of paying cash to replace both our vehicle and the others could quite possibly be over $100,000 – maybe even $200,000 if she hit the right (or wrong!) type of car. I’m somewhat embarrassed by this experience and am certainly guilty of being the ‘plumber with the leaky taps’. But I felt it was important to share, in the hope it has been a timely reminder for you to review your insurance. As a financial adviser, our domain is life insurance – the stuff that protects you, which arguably is the most critical coverage. Compared to cars, people, along with their future earning capacity, are very expensive to replace. Over the coming months, we’ll be diving deeper into the topic of life insurance. For those that are a little older, don’t switch off! Whilst you may be past the age of requiring life insurance, your kids probably are not, and there are compelling arguments for you to take an interest, but more on that in the next article!
By Todd Conklin July 11, 2024
Perhaps the best question might be, what do I do? At least for my clients, what you shouldn’t do is fret about your portfolio, because it’s not what matters.